Jack the Ripper
Updated: 4 days ago
Episodes 172, 173, & 174: Why History's Most Notorious Serial Killer Continues to Evade Us

Listen:
Watch:
Transcripts:
Part 1: It’s October 24, 1887. Protestors have gathered in Trafalgar Square, a flashpoint where London’s notoriously destitute East End meets, clashes with the wealthy West End. Trafalgar Square itself was a symbol of how disillusioned, out of touch London aristocracy had become. Built a few decades prior as a monument to commemorate the grandeur of the empire, Nelson’s Column stood at the center of the square, an impressive monolith of stone and bronze. But the working class in London was not pleased. First, the area where Trafalgar Square now stood used to be home to hundreds of working class folks, already struggling to survive. They were evicted, their shops closed, their houses demolished, and they were forced into the slums of the East End to sink or swim on their own in overcrowded, dirty, and dangerous conditions. Second, construction of Nelson’s column, a monument to honor a military hero, took way longer and cost way more than it was supposed to. The working poor were outraged that London was spending so much money on the square that no one even wanted when they could have spent it on hospitals, public housing, and much needed food instead. The poor saw the square as a hostile spatial takeover, the wealthy elite literally tearing down the spaces of the destitute to build a monument to themselves and so it was often a place of protest, like the one now taking place on October 24, 1887. Hundreds of London’s poor have gathered in the square, many have been sleeping there night after night. They are angry, unruly. They carry signs demanding basic human necessities: food, shelter, decency. They beg the government to provide jobs so they can work. They don’t want to be homeless. They want to make a life for themselves but society won’t let them. Police officers watch from the sidelines until they’ve had enough. They rush in on horseback, scattering the crowd. They hit protestors with their batons. They arrest people. On this day, 10 particularly troublesome protestors are arrested. One of them is a woman by the name of Polly Nichols. She’s immediately labeled as the most difficult one in the bunch. She resists her arrest, swears at the officers and fights back. She’s thrown in a cell for a time before, finally subdued, she’s released back onto the streets of East London. Streets where, less than a year later she’ll be found brutally murdered, the first victim of notorious serial killer, Jack the Ripper, but really, a victim of the broken society she was protesting to repair. Let’s fix that.
Hello, I’m Shea LaFountaine and you’re listening to History Fix where I tell surprising true stories from history you won’t be able to stop thinking about. I’ve been losing my voice the past couple days so this might get interesting. Bear with me folks. Today, and for the next couple weeks actually because this is a three parter, a History Fix first, we are talking about the infamous Victorian era London serial killer Jack the Ripper. I’ve resisted talking about Jack the Ripper until now because this story is so almost over covered at this point. It certainly isn’t lesser known history. But it is very misunderstood history. So my goal here is not to tell you about something you’ve never heard of, it's really to correct the mistakes and misconceptions in a story that you’re probably quite familiar with. And if you aren’t familiar with it, well then it’s both I guess. Before we go any further I want to note that this is not a story for young listeners or for the faint of heart. This is heavy and graphic and gory. So, anyone not prepared for that, turn back now. I will try to give you a heads up before I reveal anything too horrible, I’ll tell you to skip ahead however many minutes or whatever so you can decide if you want to hear the gory parts or not. But, you know, this is the story of a vicious murderer stalking and killing women for sick sadistic reasons so it really isn’t a story for young audiences. I love my young listeners but skip this one y’all.
When I told my husband Joey I was finally planning to cover Jack the Ripper he said “oh yeah, wasn’t he like the first serial killer or something?” No. He wasn’t. Not by a long shot. In fact, I already covered the person thought to be the first official serial killer last Spooktober, Gilles de Rais. That’s episode 135. Gille de Rais operated in the early 1400s, predating Jack the Ripper by almost 500 years. So if Jack the Ripper isn’t the first serial killer then surely he was the most prolific, the most violent, the most shocking. Well, no actually, he wasn’t those things either. There are serial killers with far more victims than Jack and with far more shocking modus operandis. So why is Jack the Ripper so notorious, so well known? There are a few reasons for that, but the main reason is the circumstances surrounding his killings, the context in which they took place. So, this was a time when newspapers had just become a very big thing. Newspapers were a big business in London in the 1880s. In 1884, for example, there were something like 15 evening papers, 9 weekly papers, and 383 London local newspapers. This boom is mostly due to new technology that made it much easier and cheaper to print newspapers and so more and more people can afford them, they are much less expensive, and so people are buying newspapers like crazy. You also have to realize, there’s no TV. There isn’t even radio. There certainly isn’t the internet. If you want to know what’s going on, you have to get that information from a newspaper. It’s the only way. Also, literacy rates were higher than ever. About 75% of men and 70% of women in 1880s London were literate, could read. So people are gobbling up newspapers left and right and that made the newspaper business quite lucrative.
With a highly lucrative newspaper business, money to be made, right, and lots of competing newspapers, we see more and more drastic measures being taken to sell papers. This means super interesting, attention grabbing headlines. We see sensationalized news emerge where an interesting story becomes more important than an accurate story for really the first time. Click bait… the accidental theme of this Spooktober. So Jack the Ripper absolutely blew up, went viral in modern terms, that’s what we’d call it now, not because he was the first serial killer or the most prolific or anything like that, but because he was on the frontpage of hundreds of newspapers for months and that had never really happened before with any other serial killers or murderers. It all came down to the timing, the context in which his crimes took place. And actually, most of what we know about Jack the Ripper today comes from these newspapers. And that’s part of the reason why this story has gotten so twisted because, as I said, accuracy wasn’t really their main concern. They’d write whatever they had to to sell papers. As for the police files, the actual legit documentation of these crimes, most of that has been lost. A lot of it was lost decades later during the Blitz, the bombing of London during World War II, which destroyed virtually all of the City of London Police files. And then most of what wasn’t destroyed in World War II was likely just thrown away at some point. That was common practice, to just throw away old files and evidence to make room for new stuff. Especially since this case was officially closed in 1892, four years after the murders, despite never figuring out who Jack the Ripper was. They had exhausted all of their leads, there hadn’t been a murder in 4 years, they were like “eh, oh well, toss it.”
And you have to keep in mind, these murders happened between August and November of 1888. In 1888 there’s no fingerprint technology, it’s about to emerge but the police aren’t using it yet. They certainly don’t have a database of fingerprints to compare to. There’s definitely no concept of DNA. They can’t do blood typing. They can’t even figure out if blood is animal or human. There’s virtually no forensic evidence. So the only way to solve a murder is to quite literally catch the murderer in the act. A witness has to come forth and say “I saw so and so kill so and so.” That’s the only way, eyewitnesses, and we all know how unreliable eyewitnesses can be. So getting away with murder in 1888 was actually pretty easy.
Then we also have to take into account where these murders happened and who the victims were. We don’t know for sure how many people Jack the Ripper murdered. Definitely at least 4 but maybe as many as 18 women. Most experts narrow it down to 5 women. These women are known as the canonical five and I’m going to get into each of their stories here next. These first two episodes are about the victims, the women. The third and final episode we’ll dig more into the suspects and theories. All of these women were what were referred to as “unfortunates” in Victorian England. They were destitute, they were poor, most were sex workers, forced into prostitution in order to afford a place to sleep for the night. All of them were alcoholics. That’s a strong throughline here. So, people at the time and in the decades since look at that and they say “ah, they were asking for it. Look how they lived their lives, getting drunk, soliciting strange men, sleeping on the streets. They were asking for it.” And so, with that kind of victim shaming attitude, how hard were they really trying to find this guy? If he had been murdering noble women of London’s aristocracy, would their efforts have gone farther? There was borderline an attitude at the time of “good, someone needs to get rid of these women, clean up the streets. Someone needs to cleanse our city of these unfortunates, these loose immoral women who are too lazy to work and who don’t contribute to society, who are a burden to society.” That was definitely a sentiment that went around. That’s terrible. That’s awful. Because they’re completely ignoring the context in which these women lived. They are ignoring the glaring unresolved societal issues of Victorian London that put these women in the situations they were in.
The Jack the Ripper murders took place in East London. East London, the East End, was notoriously poor. This was a place of industry, with factories where people worked long hours for little money. There were docks where ships came in so there were a lot of poor immigrants in the east end as well. It was the working class part of London. The opposite of that was the West End. West London was where the aristocracy lived. It was very posh. There were fancy houses and high end shopping. It was all about the luxury and indulgence of the rich. It was well lit, dotted with gas lights. East London was dark and dirty and dangerous. So we have this major social inequality in London and it’s very very pronounced by the 1880s. It’s very apparent. There is no social security. There is no welfare. The government is not taking care of poor people or really doing anything effective to try to help poor people or remedy this socioeconomic inequality. Everything they do try to do honestly just makes things worse. Like, they set up work houses to give poor people a place to live, the idea here being that they would have a place to sleep and then they would work, they would contribute labor in return. But these were basically prisons. Families were separated. People did terrible backbreaking work for long hours, smashing up stones into gravel, untangling ropes that cut into and blistered their fingers, processing animal parts. These were all the jobs that literally no one else wanted to do. And of course they were horribly mistreated and abused, the people in these workhouses. In many cases they were starved. There are reports of people fighting over the job of processing the animal parts so that they could suck the marrow out of the animal bones they were so hungry. So, you know, any efforts the city of London was taking to remedy these socioeconomic problems were backfiring horribly. Workhouses were last resorts. People would literally rather sleep on the streets, curl up in an alley somewhere than go into a workhouse. There were lodging houses too, also called doss houses, where you could pay 4 pence for a bed for the night but come morning they kicked you out. It was just a place to sleep. You couldn’t hang out during the day and you couldn’t leave your stuff either. So many people carried all of their belongings around with them all the time. If you couldn’t afford the 4 pence for a bed, you could pay 2 pence for what was called a “twopenny hangover.” This is where, you didn’t get a bed to lay down in, but they would stretch a rope across the room and you could literally just hangover the rope to sleep. It was something to lean on. This is likely where the term “hangover,” like how bad you feel after a night of drinking, came from.
And that brings me to alcohol. What a perfect segue. Alcohol was a major societal problem at this time. A lot of these people didn’t have the 4 pence for a bed for the night because they spent it on alcohol. They are drunk a lot of the time which means, first of all they aren’t in good health, also they don’t have their wits about them at all, and also they are viewed as degenerates by society. In those days alcohol was closely linked to morality. Drinking alcohol was seen as immoral. Today that’s thankfully changed. We view alcoholism today as a disease. It’s a health condition. Back then, it was loose morals. You weren’t sick, you were just a bad person. And so the poor residents of East London were judged very harshly and unfairly by a society that had set them up to fail and was doing absolutely nothing to help them or to remedy the situation they were victims of.
That was especially true for women because women had almost no opportunities to work, to contribute to society, to earn their keep, to make a way for themselves in the world. There were really only two boxes for women, two cages for women is more appropriate, in 1880s London. Ideally you got married, you had some kids, and you were a homemaker, you took care of the house and the kids. That’s cage number one. Cage number two you worked. But there were very few working opportunities for women at that time. Men, all kinds of jobs available. Women, not so much. Working class women were mostly in service jobs as maids or housekeepers, nannies in middle class or aristocratic homes. These were jobs for single women only, spinsters. If you got pregnant, you would be fired and cast out on the streets, cageless. So, to say that there were very few opportunities for women is kind of an understatement. This is why so many of them turned to sex work because there was literally nothing else they could do to earn money. Of note, prostitution was legal in London in the 1880s but brothels were not. This meant that sex workers had nowhere safe to operate. They were operating on the streets, in back alleys, in parks, wherever they could and usually with complete strangers. So this was obviously a very dangerous situation for these women that they were forced into out of desperation.
Keeping that in mind, let’s talk about the women, the victims of Jack the Ripper. All of these women were killed in the Whitechapel district of East London between August and November of 1888. I’m just going to focus on the canonical five otherwise it would take me way more than three episodes to tell this story. Although, of note, some experts think that there is likely a sixth victim, Martha Tabram, who would have actually been the first, if she was, in fact, killed by Jack the Ripper. She was murdered on August 7th, 1888 and her body was found sprawled at the bottom of a stair landing with 39 stab wounds. 38 of the stab wounds were inflicted with a quote “ordinary pen-knife” but one looked like it had been made with something like a bayonet which led police to believe that she had been killed maybe by a soldier or sailor. So, from that, I can see why Martha Tabram is not one of the canonical five. This isn’t really Jack the Ripper’s MO. He’s a Ripper, not a stabber. But, she’s probably the closest case we have to a sixth victim, August 7th, 1888.
The first official Jack the Ripper victim was Mary Ann Nichols who went by the name Polly, Polly Nichols. Polly was born in 1845 in central London, the daughter of a blacksmith. She got married when she was 22 years old to a man named William Nichols and they had 5 children together. William was a printer which is a respectable job. It’s not a high paying job but it’s respectable. So Polly is in cage number one, remember I talked about the two cages for women at the time. She is starting out her adult life as a homemaker in a relatively poor but respectable family. But Polly and William had a really bad relationship. They fought constantly. It was not a happy home. At some point William started having an affair with the neighbor. According to Polly’s father later, this neighbor woman had cared for Polly when she gave birth to their children. William began having an affair with her. Polly was obviously heartbroken by this and she resorted to alcohol to sort of self-medicate at a time when she was quite depressed by what was happening in her relationship with her husband. She became an alcoholic, and of course this just made everything worse. The domestic disputes intensified and, when she was 34, she left her family for good. She left William and her 5 children. She left cage one. She’s cageless for a time and, like other cageless women, she most likely resorted to sex work to get by. Now, she was getting some money from William. They were separated but he had to pay her essentially alimony as his wife. He pays her a certain amount a week. Well, in 1882, he found out that she was a sex worker and he used that as evidence that she had abandoned the marriage. This was adultery right? She had abandoned the marriage and, therefore, he didn’t have to pay her anymore. Nevermind that all of this pretty much started with his own adultery, his affair with that neighbor woman. He’s never accused of abandoning the marriage, of course, only Polly. So William stops paying Polly this weekly amount. Because of this, Polly can no longer afford wherever she’s been sleeping and she is forced to enter the workhouses. She bounces around between different workhouses in the East End: Lambeth Workhouse, Giles Workhouse, Strand Workhouse, Mitcham Workhouse. At one point she moves in with her father, but that doesn’t go well. He doesn’t like her drinking. He testified later that she was a quote “dissolute character and drunkard whom he knew would come to a bad end,” end quote. He also said later quote “I don’t think she had any enemies. She was too good for that,” end quote. So that seems contradictory but I think Polly’s father loved her and wanted to help her. I think it was the alcohol that drove a wedge between them and ultimately made this living arrangement fail. Her father said that he never kicked her out but she eventually left on her own.
She went back into the workhouses for a time until she got a job as a domestic servant in May of 1888. She went to work in the home of Samuel and Sarah Cowdry in Wandsworth, a district in south London. During this time, Polly wrote a letter to her father. She wrote quote “I just right to say you will be glad to know that I am settled in my new place, and going all right up to now. My people went out yesterday and have not returned, so I am left in charge. It is a grand place inside, with trees and gardens back and front. All has been newly done up. They are teetotalers and religious so I ought to get on. They are very nice people, and I have not too much to do. I hope you are all right and the boy has work. So good bye for the present. from yours truly, Polly. Answer soon please and let me know how you are” end quote. So it seems like, you know, this seems like a good gig she has now. She’s in cage 2 now, right, domestic service. But this doesn’t last long. Polly worked at the Cowdry house for 2 months but then was dismissed after she stole some clothing and linens worth about 3 pounds, 3 shillings. Which seems crazy, right, but that’s actually quite a lot of money. 3 pounds, 3 shillings is equal to 756 pence and, if you remember, a night in a lodging or doss house cost 4 pence. So that’s 189 nights of having a bed to sleep in. Or, a large glass of gin cost 3 pence so that’s 252 glasses of gin. Makes it a bit more understandable why she would do something so obviously stupid.
So Polly left cage one and now she has been cast out of cage two and she is cageless once more. That brings us to the night of August 30, 1888. It was pouring down rain, thundering and lightning. At 11 pm, Polly is seen walking down Whitechapel Road, despite the rain. She is probably out soliciting as a sex worker, looking to make some money. Can we confirm that, no, but it’s likely. I did find that the going rate she could earn for prostitution was 2 or 3 pence or a stale loaf of bread. So, that’s pretty bleak. This is not a get rich quick scheme. One encounter would not even afford you a bed in a lodging house. It would, however, afford you a large glass of gin which, remember, cost 3 pence. And so many of these women spent their earnings on alcohol and they kept going until they’d had enough to drink, first of all, and then hopefully enough for a bed for the night although we know Polly also sometimes slept rough which meant she slept on the streets. In December of 1887 she was caught sleeping in Trafalgar Square and was sent to a workhouse. So we know she had to resort to this at times.
On the night of August 30th, she is seen walking in a thunderstorm at 11 pm. At 12:30 am there are reports of her leaving a pub called the Frying Pan and she goes back to the lodging house where she is hoping to sleep. She doesn’t have enough money for a bed though so she is just hanging out in the kitchen of the lodging house. At around 1:30 am she gets kicked out because she doesn’t have the money to stay. They kick her out into a thunderstorm. She reportedly asked the lodging house guy to save her a bed and said quote “Never mind! I’ll soon have my doss money. See what a jolly bonnet I’ve got now,” end quote. She was talking about a black velvet bonnet she was wearing that no one had ever seen her wear before.
At 2:30 am she runs into a woman she knows out on the streets named Emily Holland. Emily would later testify that Polly was quote “very drunk and staggered against the wall,” end quote. Emily said Polly told her that she had had her doss money three times that day and drank it away. They talked for a few minutes and then went their separate ways. We know this was at 2:30 am because Emily mentioned hearing the church bells chime.
Fast forward to 3:15 am, on a street called Bucks Row which runs parallel to Whitechapel Street where Polly and Emily had stopped to chat. At 3:15 two police officers pass down Buck’s row on their usual patrol and don’t see anything. Everything is normal. Then, at 3:40 or 3:45, so about 30 minutes later, a man named Charles Cross was heading to work when he noticed a woman lying on the sidewalk. Now, this wasn’t that crazy of a thing to come across at this time and in this place. Sleeping rough was a thing. Sometimes people resorted to sleeping on the streets. Sometimes people passed out drunk on the streets. But Charles realizes something is off with this one. He calls to another man named Robert Paul to come check her out with him. The two men report that the woman’s face and hands are cold but the rest of her is warm. Also she appears to have a faint heartbeat. But then, get this, they don’t want to be late for work so they just take off. They just leave her there. They’re gonna tell the first police officer they see. Before they even get to, another police officer finds Polly and he calls for a Dr. Lewellyn who lives nearby. Dr. Lewellyn examines the body and pronounces that she is dead quote “but a few minutes,” meaning she probably was alive when Charles and Robert found her. But, honestly, there’s really nothing they could have done anyway.
Skip forward about a minute if you don’t want to hear the extent of her injuries. This one’s not that bad but, still, I promised I’d warn you. Polly’s throat had been slit with an 8 inch gash, essentially from ear to ear. This was a very deep cut, all the way down to the vertebrae and it had severed the arteries on either side of the neck. It’s likely this is what ultimately killed her, she bled out. Although, of note, it looked like she had also been strangled somewhat. According to inquest testimony that was reported in the Times newspaper quote “There was a bruise running along the lower part of the jaw on the right side of the face. That might have been caused by a blow from a fist or pressure from a thumb. There was a circular bruise on the left side of the face which also might have been inflicted by the pressure of the fingers,” end quote. There was no blood on her chest or down her front which you might expect if her throat had been cut while she was standing. So this leads us to believe that she was first strangled, grabbed by the neck by someone facing her and forced onto the ground, lying on her back. Then her throat was slashed. All the blood is pooled under her neck and head which indicates that that happened while she was laying on the ground. Her only other injury is to her lower abdomen. According to that inquest testimony quote “There were no injuries about the body until just about the lower part of the abdomen. Two or three inches from the left side was a wound running in a jagged manner. The wound was a very deep one, and the tissues were cut through. There were several incisions running across the abdomen. There were three or four similar cuts running downwards, on the right side, all of which had been caused by a knife which had been used violently and downwards,” end quote.
Polly had been killed in a highly populated, though very dark, area. There were people sleeping in the houses all around her. She had been killed literally right under the bedroom window where a woman named Emma Green was sleeping. Emma said she was a very light sleeper but that she wasn’t woken up until police arrived. So this means her attack probably happened very quickly. He likely had her down on the ground and slashed her throat pretty much instantly, which severed her windpipe and would have made it impossible for her to yell out. So this was, you know, this was horrifying. It was a brutal murder that had taken place out in the open where anyone one could have walked up on it. It was brazen. It was bold. But, at this point, it was a one off thing and, unfortunately, it wasn’t all that uncommon. There was a lot of violence on the streets of East London. This was just another murder of a quote “unfortunate,” and in the minds of many Londoners, the city was better off for it.
But Polly Nichol’s murder, turns out, was not a one off thing. It was only the beginning. And that takes us to our next victim, Annie Chapman. Annie was born in 1841 which made her 3 or 4 years older than Polly. Polly was 44 when she was killed, Annie would lose her life at 47. But, before all that, Annie was born the daughter of a member of the household cavalry. These were guards who protected the royal family. So her father had a very respectable job which makes the path Annie’s life would take all the more surprising. When she was 12 years old, 4 of her siblings died of scarlet fever within 3 weeks. This was absolutely devastating to the family. Her father never got over it. He turned to alcohol to drown out his depression but ultimately took his own life 9 years later. After that, Annie’s mother was forced to take in lodgers to make ends meet. One of those lodgers was a man named John Chapman. Annie married John when she was 28 years old.
John Chapman was a coachman, he drove carriages for people. This was a high paying, high ranking domestic service job and it took the couple to the country estate of his employer where they lived in their own home on the property. Okay so they’re doing well. There is a portrait, a photograph of Annie and John Chapman, you’re seeing it now if you’re watching the video version of this on either YouTube or Patreon. This is in the style of a portrait that would have been taken to display over a mantel, over a fireplace. Well, if you had a mantel, you had a parlor, which meant you were relatively well off. You had your own home with a parlor that’s more of a middle class thing. Annie and John had 3 children but tragedy would strike her home once again. Their youngest son was born with some sort of deformity, he was crippled, and so he was sent off to live at a home for children with disabilities which I imagine was not a good situation in, this would have been in the 1870s. Their oldest daughter died of meningitis at the age of 12. So Annie had 3 children but she really only had one who survived, a daughter.
This is, you know, once again, devastating. Just like her father before her, Annie turned to alcohol to cope and quickly became an alcoholic like her father had been. She actually spent a year in rehab but, after returning home, quickly relapsed. And this led to the destruction of her marriage. John also drank, he was likely also an alcoholic. So it was a bad situation. Annie and John separated in probably 1884 and John paid Annie 10 shillings a week as a sort of alimony. But then John died in 1886 of cirrhosis of the liver which is why I think he was also an alcoholic. Annie was reportedly very sad over the death of John even though they had been separated for the past couple years. Annie had actually walked the 25 miles on foot from London to Windsor where John lived to try to visit him before he died but arrived too late.
After that is when, it seems she may have turned to prostitution, after that weekly payment from her now dead husband stops. She relies on money from sex work to afford beds in lodging houses and she’s hanging out with kind of a rough crew at this point. She’s also not in good health herself. She complained to several people in early September of 1888 that she was not well. A bottle of medicine was found in the room where she had been staying after her death. And that brings us to Friday, September 7, 1888. At around 5 pm, Annie’s friend Amelia Palmer reports seeing her on the streets and she appeared to be sober. She said something like “I must pull myself together and go out and get some money or I shall have no lodgings.”
By 11:30 pm Annie returns to the lodging house, apparently still without the money because she asks if she can just hang out in the kitchen. At 12:10 am, now on September 8th, a fellow lodger named Frederick Stevens said he drank a pint of beer with Annie in the kitchen and that she seemed quite drunk already, which probably explains why she didn’t have her lodging money. According to Frederick, Annie left the lodging house at 1:00 am. She comes back at 1:35 reportedly eating a baked potato. I love this. This has to be the Victorian London equivalent of drunk food, like pokey sticks or cookout. She gets her a baked potato and she comes back. But she still doesn’t have the money for a bed. She tells the night watchmen to hold her bed for her and that she’s going to go out and get the money and she’ll be right back. And so she leaves the lodging house again just before 2 am, heading towards Spitalfields Market. Spitalfields is a neighborhood in Whitechapel. Spital comes from the word hospital, not like drool. I know, it’s not a very appetizing name Spitalfields but it’s not actually referring to spit. So Annie leaves again to get this doss money and she never comes back.
That takes us to 29 Hanbury Street. This was another sort of lodging house where about 16 people lived. There were so many people coming and going at all hours of the night and day that the front door was sort of always open. You could pass right through the house and go out into a small fenced backyard behind it. This is something that people off the street, prostitutes and rough sleepers would have known about. It was relatively private compared to, you know, just sleeping on the street. So people who didn’t even live at 29 Hanbury would have frequented this back yard. A woman named Elizabeth Long reported seeing Annie in that backyard of 29 Hanbury around 5:30 am talking to a man but she couldn’t see the man’s face. He had his back to her. She hears the man ask “will you?” and Annie replies “yes.” Just after that a man named Albert Cadosch who lived next door went out into his own backyard to use the outhouse. It was separated from the 29 Hanbury yard by a 5 foot fence and it was pitch black dark so he couldn’t really see anything but he said he heard voices. All he could make out was a woman saying “no” and then he heard something falling into the fence. He doesn’t think anything of it, carries on with his business. It’s not unusual for people to be out at night doing weird things. He didn’t want to get involved.
Just before 6 am, John Davis, who lived at 29 Hanbury street, walked out into the backyard and discovered the body of Annie Chapman laying at the bottom of the steps, sort of between the steps and the fence. The state she was left in shows a clear escalation from the murder of Polly Nichols about a week before. Maybe the killer had more time, maybe he was just becoming more bold as serial killers are known to do. According to the inquest testimony which is really long so I’m just going to summarize it, also skip ahead about a minute if you don’t want to hear this part, her face was swollen and her tongue was protruding from her mouth as if she had been strangled. Her throat was also cut deeply as Polly Nichol’s had been. It had definitely been cut while she was laying on the ground because blood was splattered on the fence next to her head about 14 inches off the ground. Her neck was so deeply cut that it looked like the killer was trying to actually sever her head from her body, like cut through the vertebrae in her neck. Her abdomen had been cut all the way down and laid open. This is where the mutilation of Annie Chapman goes beyond that of Polly Nichols. This is that escalation I was talking about. He opened up her abdomen completely. Her intestines had been removed and placed above her shoulder. Her uterus and part of her bladder had also been removed and were nowhere to be found. The inquest testimony notes quote “Obviously the work was that of an expert- of one, at least, who had such knowledge of anatomical or pathological examinations as to be enabled to secure the pelvic organs with one sweep of the knife, which must therefore must have at least 5 or 6 inches in length, probably more. The appearance of the cuts confirmed him [him being the doctor who responded to the scene] in the opinion that the instrument, like the one which divided the neck, had been of a very sharp character. The mode in which the knife had been used seemed to indicate great anatomical knowledge. He thought he himself could not have performed all the injuries he described, even without a struggle, under a quarter of an hour. If he had done it in a deliberate way such as would fall to the duties of a surgeon it probably would have taken him the best part of an hour," end quote. But of course we know the killer did not have the best part of an hour because Annie was seen alive right there in the yard at 5:30 and then discovered, dead, just before 6:00.
The report also showed that she suffered from possibly tuberculosis or maybe syphilis, maybe both. It says quote “the deceased was far advanced in disease of the lungs and membranes of the brain,” end quote. This possibly explains why Annie wasn’t feeling well in the days leading up to her death and why she was taking medicine that was later found in a room where she often slept. She was already dying when she was killed.
Annie’s death, as the second Ripper victim, is significant because it shows a clear escalation from that of Polly Nichols. Her body was much more badly mutilated, whole organs were removed and missing. And this gives us a really powerful clue as to who this guy might have been. The doctor said that, what he saw, looked like it had been done by someone with a lot of anatomical knowledge. Not just anyone could have done that so precisely to Annie, not so quickly, and not in the pitch black dark as the yard would have been at that time. This was someone who knew what they were doing. The brutality of this murder, the escalation from that of Polly Nichols, led to an absolute field day in the press. Who was this monster who could cleanly remove a uterus with one swipe of his knife in the dark and with potential witnesses all around? This was the stuff of nightmares. London was horrified. But, here’s the thing, they kind of liked being horrified. They loved gruesome murders and tales full of blood and gore. Those sorts of stories were trending in Victorian England at this time where they ran to purchase penny dreadfuls, pamphlets full of horror stories and violent crime. Now the newspaper stories satiated their morbid curiosities. But the Whitechapel murders, as they were coming to be called, were far from over and the brutality would continue to escalate over the next two months, far beyond the Victorian gore lovers' wildest dreams. That’s next week, don’t miss it.
Part 2: Louis Diemshutz squints his eyes against the pitch black night. It’s been a long day and he just wants to get home. He urges his horse down Berner Street, hooves click clacking on the rough cobbles, the faint squealing of wheels as his cart bumps along. Louis is a salesman. He’s been out peddling cheap jewellery at markets since 11 am this morning. Now it’s late, well early really, about 1:00 am. He’s loaded his leftover wares into his cart and hitched it to his horse. Just a bit further down Berner Street now and he’ll be home and can rest. As he approaches the gate leading into Dutfield’s Yard, a narrow enclosed courtyard leading off Berner Street, his horse whinnies faintly and stops, hooves dug firmly into the road. The creature's body is tense. It shies away, attempting to back up away from the gate. Louis urges the beast on, pulling on the reins, but she won’t budge. Something has spooked her. He stops pulling and squints into the yard past the gate. Is someone there? It’s far too dark to see, complete darkness. He uses the handle of his whip to reach into the darkness ahead of him, right by the gate. It strikes something with a dull thud. Thinking quickly, Louis lights a match. It flares brightly and in an instant goes out. But in the momentary burst of light Louis has seen what lies in the darkness. It’s the body of a woman lying on the ground, crumpled and still. Is she passed out drunk? Is she dead? He doesn’t stick around to find out. He runs off to get help. But there’s someone else there too. With Louis no longer blocking his only escape out of Dutfield’s Yard, a killer stalks off into the night, his thirst for murder unsatiated, ready to strike again. Let’s fix that.
Hello I’m Shea LaFountaine and you’re listening to History Fix where I tell surprising true stories from history you won’t be able to stop thinking about. This is part 2 of a 3 part series on the notorious Victorian London serial killer known as Jack the Ripper. If you missed part 1 which was last week’s episode, you should probably go back and listen to that one now and then pick back up with this one after. I will do a quick recap of what I talked about in the last episode since it’s been a whole week and you might have forgotten. First, I explained the context in which the Jack the Ripper murders, or Whitechapel murders as they were called at first, happened. These murders took place in East London where the poorest, most destitute of the working class lived, and they took place at a time when socioeconomic inequality in London was really becoming a problem. I mean, it had always sort of been a problem but people are becoming more and more vocal about it with regular protests in places like Trafalgar Square.
I talked about the first two Ripper victims, Polly Nichols and Annie Chapman and detailed what little we know about their lives and their final moments leading up to the discovery of their bodies, Polly on August 31, 1888 and Annie about a week later on September 8th. What had been done to the body of Annie Chapman, the clean removal of entire organs, was a clear escalation from Polly’s murder. Both women had had their throats slashed deeply, severing arteries which likely killed them fairly quickly. But the killer went much farther in the mutilation of Annie’s body afterwards. So this was really shocking to the public. Polly’s murder was seen as a one off thing. Now we have a serial killer on our hands, and one that is escalating in brutality and depravity. Will he strike again? When and where and who?
I also talked last week about how big a role the newspapers played in the eternal infamy of Jack the Ripper. This was a time when newspapers had become a very big business. Well now, especially after the second murder, the newspapers are having a field day. There is a media frenzy and they will publish absolutely anything to sell these papers and to outsell the many many competing newspapers that exist.
After the second murder, a suspect comes to light. The police are going around Whitechapel and interviewing as many people as they can, which you have to image, I mean we’re talking about hundreds of people living on a single block. These people are jammed into these lodging houses, living on top of one another. There is a super high population density in Whitechapel at around 800 people per acre. So just trying to interview everyone who lived in the area of these murders was a logistical nightmare, especially without computers. But, as they are talking to the residents of Whitechapel, a name keeps popping up: John Pizer, alias “leather apron.” John Pizer was a Polish bootmaker who lived in Whitechapel and he was not a very nice guy. He was sort of known for terrorizing and abusing prostitutes, women. So, when they found a leather apron in the backyard of 29 Hanbury Street where Annie Chapman was killed, a lot of people’s minds immediately jumped to John Pizer whose nickname of course was “leather apron.” It didn’t help that Pizer took off and sort of went into hiding as soon as the newspapers started printing his name. This was confirmation to a lot of folks that he was guilty. They published descriptions of him. He was about 5 foot 4 inches tall, with dark hair and a dark mustache, and he looked like he might be Jewish. Now, the police end up finding John Pizer just a few days later and he has solid alibis for both murders. He couldn’t have killed either woman. He says he ran because he was afraid the public, like an angry mob of civilians was going to attack him after his name was printed in the newspaper as a possible suspect, which like… fair. But I do think him being wrongfully named as a suspect early on, left a lasting impact on the investigation and on who people thought they were looking for. That physical description, sort of short and stocky, dark hair, dark mustache, Jewish looking, sticks. That becomes the physical description of Jack the Ripper despite John Pizer being cleared as a suspect. Also, we see people start looking at London’s Jewish population with a lot of suspicion. There’s a lot of anti-semitism at this time so any chance to point a finger of blame at the Jews, they’re going to take it. But this really just confuses things and muddies the water. Now we have this clear description of a man on everyone’s minds but, in reality, we have no idea what this guy looks like. He might be 6 foot tall and blonde.
As the newspaper frenzy continues throughout September, people begin to fear that the police are not doing enough. They form their own vigilante groups and they wait with bated breath for the next murder to happen. But it doesn’t and it doesn’t. Weeks go by without a murder. The newspapers start to run out of things to write about. They are recycling the same old information over and over again and their sales start to plummet. This is when the Dear Boss letter comes in on September 27th. So, to be clear, the police and the newspapers have received tons and tons of letters regarding these murders. Some contain useless tips, some are people claiming to be the murderer. All of those are obviously fake, hoaxes. Then we have the Dear Boss letter.
On September 27, the Central News Agency received a letter claiming to be from the killer. Here’s what it said: Dear Boss, I keep on hearing the police have caught me but they wont fix me just yet. I have laughed when they look so clever and talk about being on the right track. That joke about Leather Apron gave me real fits. I am down on whores and I shant quit ripping them till I do get buckled. Grand work the last job was. I gave the lady no time to squeal. How can they catch me now. I love my work and want to start again. You will soon hear of me with my funny little games. I saved some of the proper red stuff in a ginger beer bottle over the last job to write with but it went thick like glue and I cant use it. Red ink is fit enough I hope ha. ha. The next job I do I shall clip the ladys ears off and send to the police officers just for jolly wouldn't you. Keep this letter back till I do a bit more work, then give it out straight. My knife's so nice and sharp I want to get to work right away if I get a chance. Good Luck. Yours truly, Jack the Ripper Dont mind me giving the trade name PS Wasnt good enough to post this before I got all the red ink off my hands curse it. No luck yet. They say I'm a doctor now. ha ha,” end quote.
This letter is mostly significant because it’s the first time we see the name Jack the Ripper which will obviously stick. But there are a few really good reasons why most experts believe this letter was a hoax. First, it was sent to the Central News Agency. This was basically an agency that essentially sold stories to all of the various newspapers. It was a distributor of news. It’s not really something most people even knew existed outside of people who worked in the newspaper business. So, if it really was sent by the killer, it’s weird that he would send it there and not just straight to the police or straight to a particular newspaper. Second, the part that doesn’t sit well with me, he wrote quote “I saved some of the proper red stuff [meaning blood] in a ginger beer bottle over the last job to write with but it went thick like glue and I can’t use it. Red ink is fit enough I hope ha ha,” end quote. Not buying it. Not buying that this guy didn’t realize blood would congeal pretty much immediately after leaving the body. The expertise with which the organs of Annie Chapman were removed suggested this guy had in depth anatomical knowledge and a lot of experience chopping up bodies. There’s no way he’d make that mistake with the blood in the ginger beer bottle. And finally, the third reason most experts believe this letter is fake is because, in 1931, so 43 years later, a journalist named Fred Best reportedly confessed to his colleague at the Star Newspaper that he had written the letter as a hoax in order to boost newspaper sales. So there’s that. Why are we even talking about it? Well it’s where the name Jack the Ripper came from. I honestly feel weird calling the killer Jack the Ripper after realizing that the name was most likely made up by a newspaper journalist. It feels kind of silly now.
So no murders now for 20 some days. That brings us to the third victim of the canonical five, these five women who were believed to have been killed by Jack the Ripper. Elizabeth Stride will become the third victim, although there are some who don’t think she is a Ripper victim. I do. I think she is. You can decide for yourself after hearing her story. Elizabeth Stride was actually Swedish. She was born in 1843 on a farm in Gothenburg, Sweden. That would make her 44 years old when she was killed. Elizabeth’s life in Sweden seemed tough. Based on the records that we have. We know that she worked as a domestic servant for a time. It seems she became pregnant and was sort of cast out of that job and then gave birth to a stillborn baby girl. In March of 1865 she was registered by police in Sweden as a prostitute. Prostitution was legal in Sweden but you had to register and report for regular health exams, this was their way of trying to cut down on the spread of venereal diseases. So we have Elizabeth registered as a sex worker in Sweden.
In 1866 she moved to London. In 1869 she married a man named John Stride and the two open a coffee shop together. They are really trying to make a go of things but the coffee shop doesn’t do well. They are very poor, they have no money, Elizabeth is turning more and more to alcohol. And then, an opportunity presents itself to her. In 1878 there was a terrible shipwreck in the Thames, two steamships collided, the Princess Alice and the Bywell Castle, these two ships ran into each other and some 600 to 700 people were killed, passengers. This was such a shocking tragedy that charity organizations were offering financial help to victims. Like, if your husband was killed on the Princess Alice you can get some money to help you pay the bills and feed your kids and whatnot. Well Elizabeth hatches a rather sinister plan. She goes to the Swedish Church and tells them that her husband and her children were killed in this shipwreck, to try to get some of this charity money from them. This is not true, her husband is actually still alive. And she gets sort of called out for this lie but she doesn’t back down. She continues to try to spread this lie for the rest of her life for whatever reason.
John Stride does eventually die in 1884 and Elizabeth takes up with a man named Michael Kidney. This is not a great relationship. Kidney’s not a very nice guy. This seems pretty toxic. In 1887 Elizabeth charged Kidney with assault but then never showed up in court so the charges were dropped. We also have records of her getting arrested for drunk and disorderly conduct 8 times in the 20 months before her death while she’s with Michael Kidney. She’s in and out of workhouses. It’s not a good situation. And that brings us to the night of September 29th, leading into the early morning hours of September 30th.
A lot a lot of people saw Elizabeth Stride that night. There are all sorts of witness reports of where she was and what she was doing that night, almost too many. It actually gets really confusing because there are all these conflicting reports. There are several reports of people seeing her earlier in the evening, 6:30 pm she’s at the Queen’s Head Public House. Between 7:00 and 8:00 she talks to a few different people outside the lodging house where she’s staying. At 11:00 pm she is seen leaving another pub with a man who is described as being short with a dark mustache and sandy eyelashes. He was wearing a bowler hat and a mourning suit. The man was hugging and kissing Elizabeth which surprised witnesses at the pub because he seemed respectably dressed and she was, you know, not very respectable. They leave the pub together.
At 11:45 pm she is seen with what appears to be a different man. He’s reported as wearing a short black cutaway coat and a sailor hat. Okay so unless guy number one completely changed his outfit, this is a different guy. They are also seen hugging and kissing and the man says to her quote “you would say anything but your prayers.”
At 12:35 am she is seen with what appears to be yet another man standing on Berner Street. This one is described as 28 years old, wearing a dark coat and a deerstalker hat. I don’t know how you would know that someone is 28 years old by looking at them. That is far too specific, but whatever, late 20s. A deerstalker hat is like the hat that Sherlock Holmes wears. That’s the best way I can describe it. It’s tweed, it’s like a tweed fabric and it has flaps that come down and cover your ears. So once again, totally different outfit, totally different hat at the very least. This seems like a different guy. Of note, this third guy is carrying a package wrapped in newspaper that is described as being about 18 inches long and 6 inches high. I think that’s very interesting. Is it possible he was carrying something like a knife in that package? But I don’t know, I kind of don’t think she would be seen with the killer. I kind of think the real killer jumped out from the shadows. I don’t really think he’d be hanging out with her beforehand, but who knows.
12:45 am, so literally 10 minutes later, she’s seen with another man. This guy reportedly threw her down on the ground and she screamed three times. And, of note, this was very close to the exact location where her body would later be found. This guy was described as about 30 years old, 5’5” with dark hair and a small brown mustache. But then there’s a sighting of her with yet another man at the same time in another location. This guy was said to be a stout 5’7” in a long black coat that reached his heels. So, if you’re counting, that’s 5 different men, all with different physical descriptions. Too many witnesses. Too many witness accounts.
What we do know is that, at 1:00 am a salesman named Louis Diemshutz (Deem-shutz) approached Dutfield’s Yard with his horse and cart. This is the scene I imagined in the intro. Dutfield’s Yard was a narrow, private courtyard off of Berner Street where Elizabeth was reportedly seen a few times with various men. It’s separated from Berner Street by a gate. This Louis guy is a approaching the gate that leads into Dutfields Yard and his horse suddenly starts acting funny. The horse stops walking, refuses to keep going as if something is in the way, but its pitch black dark so Louis can’t see what’s spooked the horse. He uses his whip to sort of feel around in the dark and that’s when he comes upon a body laying just by the gate leading into Dutfield’s Yard. He immediately goes to get help and at 1:16 am a Dr. Frederick Blackwell pronounced Elizabeth dead at the scene.
According to the post mortem exam which was performed by the same guy that did Polly Nichols and Annie Chapman, Dr. George Bagster Phillips, Elizabeth’s throat had been slashed, severing the left carotid artery. But that was it. There were no other injuries to her body. So, some people look at that and they say “well hey that’s a descalation. That’s not how serial killers operate. Elizabeth Stride’s body should have been even more mutilated than the last victim, not less. She must not have been a Ripper victim after all.” I think she was. I think he was interrupted and had to flee the scene before he was done. I think he would have mutilated Elizabeth’s body more than Annie’s if Louis Diemshutz didn’t walk up with his horse and interrupt the whole operation. In fact, I think the killer was likely still right there when Louis walked up which is why the horse was so spooked. It was so incredibly dark Louis couldn’t see anything but I think the horse could sense that there was another person there in the dark and that’s what spooked it. Then Louis goes to get help and the killer runs away. That’s what I think. And really, if the killer was in Dutfield’s Yard, his only way out would have been through that gate which Louis was blocking. When Louis left to get help, that’s when the killer would have been able to flee the scene. So, I really do think he was standing right there in the dark when Louis found Elizabeth’s body.
But, this wouldn’t have satiated the killer. He wouldn’t be okay with being interrupted like that and not being able to finish the job and so he strikes again that very night, right afterwards. This becomes known as the double event. And so that brings us to our fourth victim, Catherine Eddowes. Catherine, like the three victims before her, was also in her 40s when she was killed. Her early life is a bit murky. We know that she was born in 1842, the daughter of a tin plate worker. Some reports claim that she was one of 12 children but that both parents died in 1851. At that time, many of the children went into workhouses. Catherine went to live with her aunt. When she was 21 years old, she became involved with a man named Thomas Conway. Although they never seem to have gotten married, Catherine and Thomas took off to London together and appear to have had 3 children. They go around selling gallows ballads which are like poems that they sold at executions. So, if you went to an execution, a hanging, which of course were public, you could buy one of these one page printed gallows ballads as basically a souvenir. And it had a poem on it that gave details about the crime, the trial, and the now execution of the condemned person. Kind of weird but that’s what Catherine and Thomas did. They sold gallows ballads.
But Catherine and Thomas parted ways in 1881 and she moved into a lodging house in Whitechapel. There she met another man named John Kelly. John Kelly actually seems like a pretty decent guy and Catherine seems pretty happy with him. The deputy at the lodging house where she stayed described her as quote “not often in drink and was a very jolly woman, often singing,” end quote. He also said that he didn’t think she was a sex worker. She was typically home around 9 or 10 at night and was not known to walk the streets. She seemed to be faithful to John Kelly whom she lived with as a sort of common law marriage deal but they weren’t actually married. So Catherine is different from our other victims so far in that she doesn’t, at least initially, appear to be an alcoholic or a sex worker. I though I do suspect she was actually an alcoholic.
Every year Catherine and John would go hop picking in the country. This is something people could do to make a little money. And so they do that in the fall of 1888. They walk over 40 miles to Kent to these hop fields. But, unfortunately, it wasn’t a good season for hops and there weren’t really any to pick. It’s a total bust and they pretty much just have to turn around and walk all the way home and they have no money when they get there. They are pawning their clothing to try to afford food and lodgings which is so heartbreaking considering they really tried, you know. They walked over 40 miles to go work, do honest hard labor in the fields, and it didn’t work out. It just really illustrates how much the odds were not in the favor of London’s poor. You know, it’s not that they’re lazy. It’s that they have no opportunities.
So they get back from this failed hop picking mission on September 28th. The very next night, around 8 pm, Catherine is found pretty much passed out drunk on the sidewalk. Now, a few people had said that she wasn’t a big drinker. She wasn’t known to drink that much. Well, here she is lying in a heap on the sidewalk. She is taken to the police station and put in a cell until she sobers up. When they get her there, they ask her what her name is and she replies “nothing.” By 12:15 am she is heard softly singing to herself in the cell. At 12:30 she calls out asking when she will be released. At 12:55 she is deemed sobered up enough to be released. They ask her her name again and this time she tells them it's “Mary Ann Kelly.” She likely gives them that last name Kelly because she’s in this sort of common law marriage situation with this John Kelly guy. Mary Ann, just a super common name at the time. So she gives them a fake name. They let her go right at 1:00 am.
Okay so 1:00 am, this is right about the time that the body of Elizabeth Stride was discovered outside of Dutfield’s Yard about a mile away. Catherine takes off into the night going in the opposite direction of the lodging house where she usually stayed. She didn’t seem to be going home. She seemed to be heading back towards where she had been found drunk. At 1:35 am she is seen at the corner of Duke Street and Church Passage which leads into Mitre Square. Witnesses report that they see her talking to a man and she has her hand on his chest, but not like in a defensive way. The man is described as being around 30 years old, medium build, 5 foot 7 inches tall, with a fair complexion and a mustache. He was wearing a pepper and salt colored jacket that fit loosely, and a gray cloth cap. So once again, a different guy, a different jacket, a different hat than all those men seen with Elizabeth Stride on the same night. There are so many differing descriptions of this guy it’s crazy. And that’s part of why I think none of them were the actual killer. I really think this guy stalks from the shadows. Lot of mustaches though, but I think people just tended to have mustaches in 1880s London.
So that sighting was at 1:35. Ten minutes later 1:45 her body is found in Mitre Square. Like, truly, this had to have happened so fast. Her body was found by a Police Constable, PC Edward Watkins on patrol. He had just walked past that spot at 1:30 and nothing was there. Then, on his next time around 15 minutes later, there she was. It happened in less than 15 minutes. And if that was really her talking to the man in the salt and pepper jacket at 1:35 then it happened in less than 10 minutes which is truly insane considering what was done to her body. Skip forward about a minute if you’d like to be spared this part. Once again, her throat had been slashed, severing the arteries in the neck. The face had been mutilated badly, slashed with the knife all over really. The tip of her nose had been cut off as had parts of her earlobes. She had very intentional triangular shaped cuts on each cheek. Once again, like with Annie Chapman, her intestines had been removed and placed over her right shoulder. This time, part of the intestines, about a 2 foot section, was placed between the body and the left arm. This seemed intentional. He had cut open her entire abdomen from top to bottom, messed with all kinds of stuff in there, and had cleanly removed and apparently taken her left kidney. As with Annie Chapman, the uterus had been removed and taken as well. The examiner reported quote “I believe the perpetrator of the act must have had considerable knowledge of the position of the organs in the abdominal cavity and the way of removing them. It required a great deal of medical knowledge to have removed the kidney and to know where it was placed. The parts removed would be of no use for any professional purpose,” end quote. So once again, this guy seemed to have some in depth anatomical knowledge.
A few blocks away they found a piece of Catherine’s apron with blood on it. Written in white chalk on a wall near the apron were the words quote “The Juwes are the men that will not be blamed for nothing,” end quote. Which is perplexing. Like, what does that even mean? Was it written by the killer? Was it already there? Who knows. Catherine was wearing a lot of clothing when she was found. She was wearing layers and layers of clothing. It appeared she was wearing all of the clothing that she owned and carrying all of her possessions on her person which is quite sad. She didn’t have anywhere to keep her stuff, you know. She couldn’t afford lodgings after returning from the failed hop picking mission. She had nowhere to even leave her stuff when she went off drinking that night, drowning out her sorrows. And also just the timing of all of it. She’s in a cell at the police station right up until 45 minutes before her body is found. She was safe. They let her out with nowhere to go, at the moment pretty much that Elizabeth Stride was killed a mile away. She walked out of the police station and more or less right into the killer who had just fled that scene and was probably, you know, ravenous. This desire to kill and to mutilate, it had not been satiated by Elizabeth Stride. He had been interrupted. He had not been able to finish. And so he comes upon Catherine Eddowes and she just stood no chance.
The very next day, October 1, the Central News Agency receives another letter, a postcard this time, from the same guy that wrote the Dear Boss letter, the guy going by the name Jack the Ripper. Now, remember, we don’t actually think this is the real killer. It kind of seems like this is that Fred Best guy who worked for the Star Newspaper, but I have to mention it because something really interesting happens here. This postcard, which is called the “saucy Jacky postcard” said quote “I was not codding dear old Boss when I gave you the tip, you'll hear about Saucy Jacky's work tomorrow double event this time number one squealed a bit couldn't finish straight off. Had not time to get ears off for police thanks for keeping last letter back till I got to work again. Jack the Ripper,” end quote.
So, whoever wrote this seems to know about the double event, the two killings, which he would have because this postcard was postmarked 24 hours after the bodies were found. That was enough time for word to get out. What’s interesting here, is that he doesn’t seem to know that Catherine Eddowes ears were actually severed. A piece of her ear had even dropped out of her clothing when they were taken off at the mortuary. So, in the Dear Boss letter, this guy wrote quote “The next job I do I shall clip the ladys ears off and send to the police officers just for jolly wouldn't you,” end quote. And then that actually happens. Her ears actually do get clipped off. But, the writer, who clearly isn’t the real killer, doesn't know that. That detail is not made public immediately. So in his follow up postcard he says he didn’t have time to get the ears off for police. How ironic that this little detail he included to try to seem legit is actually what makes him seem not legit. If he just hadn’t said anything about the ears in the second follow up postcard, people would have been convinced he was the killer because he just so happened to mention them in the first letter and then they really did get cut off. And then you go, well the real killer probably read the dear boss letter in the newspaper and that’s why he cut the ears off. No. Because the dear boss letter had never been published. It wasn’t published until October 4th, a few days after Catherine Eddowes was killed. So just a weird coincidence I guess.
Then, once again, everything goes quiet. Everyone was expecting another murder around a week later, around October 8th but there isn’t one. Why were they expecting that? Well they had started to pick up on a bit of a pattern. Polly Nichols was killed August 31st. Annie Chapman was killed September 8th. Then the double event happened on September 30th. If you factor in Martha Tabram, who many felt was also a Ripper victim, she was killed August 7th. So if you factor that in it goes murder on the 7th, then on the 31st, then on the 8th, then on the 30th… kind of seems like there’s going to be another one around October 7th or 8th right? But there isn’t. There is a lot of police presence after the double event. The police are out everywhere at night patrolling Whitechapel. It had become much harder to do this without being seen. So October 7th, October 8th, comes and goes… nothing.
But, something of note does happen on October 16th. Yet another letter is received by a man named George Lusk who is the head of the Whitechapel Vigilance Committee, this sort of civilian vigilante group that sprang into action to try to stop the killer when the police seemed to be failing. Lusk gets a letter also purporting to be from the murderer, except this one might actually be from the murderer. This is really the only letter received that experts and scholars take seriously and consider to be actual evidence. It’s known as the “From Hell” letter. Here’s what it says. It’s quite short. It says quote “From hell Mr Lusk, Sor I send you half the Kidne I took from one women prasarved it for you tother piece I fried and ate it was very nise. I may send you the bloody knif that took it out if you only wate a whil longer signed Catch me when you can Mishter Lusk,” end quote. With it was a small box containing half of a human kidney that had been preserved in alcohol. Of note, it was half of a left kidney which was the kidney that had been taken from Catherine Eddowes. Also, it appeared to be an unhealthy kidney. It looked diseased. Catherine was known to suffer from Brights Disease, which today we call nephritis. It’s an inflammation of the kidneys. This kidney was consistent with that. Now, George Lusk was immediately skeptical. He got hoax letters claiming to be from the killer all the time. He figured this kidney was just sent by some medical student having a good laugh. He didn’t even initially turn this into police until he was urged to do so by some of his friends.
And it’s a good thing he did because this letter is really the only of hundreds of Jack the Ripper letters that we think just might be real. A few things to note about it. It is not well written. It is riddled with spelling and grammar errors. You saw that if you’re watching the video version of this on either YouTube or Patreon. It appears the person who wrote this letter is barely literate. But, there are some inconsistencies. For example, he knows to include the letter k at the beginning of the word knife and the silent h in the word while. So is this really a barely literate person or is it misdirection. Is someone pretending to be barely literate? Another word stands out, the word preserved. He says quote “I send you half the kidney I took from one woman prasarved it for you…” Parsarved, not preserved, suggests that this guy might be Irish. He might have an Irish accent as that is how someone with an Irish accent would say the word preserved and he’s clearly spelling things phonetically here. Interestingly, a shopkeeper named Emily Marsh had told police that a visitor had come to her shop just before the letter was received. He was strange. She said he had an unsettling manner in both his speech and appearance and that he asked for the mailing address of George Lusk, the guy who would soon receive the letter. He wrote it in a small notebook and left quickly. She described this guy as a slim but tall man, about 6 feet tall, with a dark beard and mustache, wearing a long black overcoat who spoke with a distinct Irish accent. But, honestly, George Lusk received so many letters it's impossible to say whether this guy sent the From Hell letter or one of the many others. Although, I think the fact that he had an Irish accent is very interesting considering the spelling of the word preserved as parsarved.
We have a major contradiction emerging though. On the one hand, we have doctors and medical examiners saying that the killer had to have had an in-depth knowledge of anatomy and of medicine - surgery. On the other hand, we have him being barely literate in this letter. Those two things don’t jive. In my mind, either this letter is not from the killer, it's one of the many many fake letters that were received. Or, this letter is from the killer, I mean it did include half of a left kidney that could conceivably have been from Catherine Eddowes, and he has intentionally written with poor grammar and spelling to lead police astray. This means he’s one of two absolute extremes. He’s either not very intelligent, barely functioning, perhaps deranged or he’s the extreme opposite. He’s exceedingly intelligent, highly functional to the point of outwitting everyone and avoiding detection. When you look at what he’s gotten away with so far and, you know, in hindsight looking back and knowing that he was never caught. It kind of seems like the latter doesn’t it? He kind of seems like a serial killer of the exceedingly intelligent, highly functional sort and not just a deranged lunatic off the streets. Those guys don’t tend to get so very lucky as Jack the Ripper had been.
But whether the From Hell letter is real or not, our Saucy Jack is not done. Sure, he’s biding his time for now but he’ll soon strike again and his final act will surely be his magnum opus. Join me next week for the horrifying conclusion to Jack the Ripper’s reign of terror.
Part 3: Four grisly murders have already been attributed to a bloodthirsty serial killer stalking the streets of Whitechapel in London’s notoriously poor East End. A fifth is soon to follow and this one will be hard to even comprehend, the level of violence and depravity, the mutilation beyond anyone’s wildest imagination. This will be the killer’s magnum opus, the culmination of his brutal body of work. In the end, it will leave even gore loving Victorian Londoners frozen in shock. They had hungrily gobbled up the news, the drama, the twists and turns, every last juicy detail of this case for months, their morbid curiosity getting the best of them. They flocked to news stands daily to consume the latest on the case. Who was this monster? What exactly had he done? And when would he strike again? Let’s fix that.
Hello, I’m Shea LaFountaine and you’re listening to History Fix where I tell surprising true stories from history you won’t be able to stop thinking about. I realize it’s solidly no longer October but I am back once more with part 3, the final installment, of my three part series on notorious Victorian London serial killer Jack the Ripper. I did not mean for Spooktober to bleed over into November. I genuinely thought I could cover Jack the Ripper in 2 episodes but I was very mistaken. I am honestly questioning whether I can wrap everything up in 3 still at this point. But here goes. If you missed part 1 and part 2 of course go back and listen to those first. And, same disclaimer as in those episodes, this is not a topic for young ears. This episode in particular is going to get real gory so turn back now.
Here’s where we left off. It’s the fall of 1888 in Whitechapel which is a notoriously poor neighborhood in the notoriously poor East End of London. At least four women have been killed so far by the same murderer. How do we know that? Because he has a very specific MO. That MO, by the way, was not actually officially defined until the early 2000s, over a hundred years after the murders which is kind of wild to me. That’s just because this wasn’t something they were doing when the case was active back in the 1880s and early 1890s. Police weren’t profiling serial killers. They weren’t looking at these sorts of patterns like we do today to try to understand who this guy is. We’re going to get into Jack the Ripper’s criminal profile in a little bit but his MO, his modus operandi, officially defined in the early 2000s is as follows. According to Casebook.org which is the largest public online repository and historical resource dedicated to Jack the Ripper quote “The Whitechapel murderer and his victim stood facing each other. When she lifted her skirts, the victim's hands were occupied and was then defenseless. The Ripper seized the women by their throats and strangled them until they were unconscious if not dead. The autopsies constantly revealed clear indications that the victims had been strangled… The Ripper then lowered his victims to the ground, their heads to his left. This has been proven by the position of the bodies in relation to walls and fences that show that there was virtually no room for the murderer to attack the body from the left side. No bruising on the back of the heads shows that he lowered the bodies to the ground rather than throwing or letting them fall… He cut the throats when the women were on the ground. Splatter stains show that the blood pooled beside or under the neck and head of the victim rather than the front which is where the blood would flow if they had been standing up. In one case blood was found on the fence some 14 inches or so from the ground and opposite the neck wound and this shows that the blood spurted from the body while in the prone position on the ground. This method also prevented the killer from being unduly blood stained. By reaching over from the victim's right side to cut the left side of her throat, the blood flow would have been directed away from him, which would have reduced the amount of blood in which he would have been exposed. If the victim was already dead before their throats were cut, then the blood spilt would have not been very much. With the heart no longer beating the blood would not have been "pressurized," so only the blood in the immediate area of the wound would have evacuated gently from the cuts. The Ripper then made his other mutilations, still from the victim's right side, or possibly while straddling over the body at or near the feet. In several cases the legs had been pushed up which would have shortened the distance between the abdomen and the feet. No sign of intercourse was ever detected nor did the Ripper masturbate over the bodies. Usually he took a piece of the victim's viscera. The taking of a "trophy" is a common practice by modern sexual serial killers. In the opinion of most of the surgeons who examined the bodies, most believed that the killer had to have some degree of anatomical knowledge to do what he did. In one case he removed a kidney from the front rather than from the side, and did not damage any of the surrounding organs while doing so. In another case he removed the sexual organs with one clean stroke of the knife. Given the time circumstances of the crimes (outside, often in near total darkness, keeping one eye out for the approach of others, and under extremely tight time constraints), the Ripper almost certainly would have had some experience in using his knife,” end quote.
So, super consistent MO in each of these 4 cases. The victims were of a very similar type as well. They had similar victim profiles. Polly Nichols, Annie Chapman, Elizabeth Stride, and Catherine Eddowes were all in their mid forties. They all bounced around between workhouses and lodging houses in Whitechapel. They were, at least most of them, were most likely sex workers out of desperation in order to earn enough money to afford a bed for the night. Most of them, possibly all of them, were also alcoholics. This was a clear obstacle that these women faced because, in many cases, we see this over and over again, we see them spending what little money they have made on alcohol instead of on a bed for the night in a doss house or lodging house. I mentioned, I think, in the first episode, one encounter with a man as a sex worker would earn you as much as 3 pence. A large glass of gin cost 3 pence. A bed in a doss house cost 4 pence. So they get that money, they still don’t have enough for a bed. They do have enough for a drink. What would you do if you were an alcoholic?
So we left off in the last episode with the From Hell letter which is significant because many experts believe that it might have actually been written by the killer unlike the hundreds of other letters that were received. The From Hell letter included half of a human kidney that could have been, was consistent with, the kidney taken from the 4th victim, Catherine Eddowes. So 4 murders down, the 3rd and 4th happening on the same night, the double event on September 30th. People are expecting a 5th murder around October 8th because a bit of a pattern has emerged. It’s gone murder on the 8th, then the 30th, then the 8th, then the 30th or thereabouts. October 8th comes and goes… nothing. October 30th comes and goes… nothing. An entire month has passed and all is quiet. Now it’s early November… nothing. Honestly, it’s fitting that Spooktober spilled over into November. It’s early November in our story too. I’m right on schedule y’all.
All quiet until November 9th. This is when Jack the Ripper kills the 5th of the canonical five victims, these 5 women who are widely believed to be the sole victims, despite up to 13 other maybes. The 5th killing is different from the others. Same MO ultimately which is why it gets linked to Jack the Ripper, but there are several key differences. These differences are more escalations than they are deviations from the MO though. This murder is insane. It is so over the top. Seriously, turn back now if you’re questioning whether you can handle it or not. You can’t unhear this one. The 5th of the canonical five victims is Mary Jane Kelly. She’s already different from the four who came before her because she was only 25 years old at the time of her death. The others were in their 40s. We don’t know much at all about the early life of Mary Jane Kelly. Because she was 25 when she died, she would have been born around 1863. She had blonde hair, blue eyes, and a fair complexion. She’s been described as quite beautiful or she was quote “said to have possessed of considerable personal attractions.” That’s the Victorian version of saying she was a baddie. Mary Jane Kelly was a baddie. Girl was a dime piece.
We believe Mary Jane was born in Ireland but later moved to Wales with her family as a child. She apparently spoke fluent Welsh so that backs up that detail. People who knew Mary Jane said that she came from a family that was quote “fairly well off” and quote “well to do people.” She seems to have gotten married when she was 16 but her husband was killed in an explosion a couple years later. At that point she moves in with a cousin and begins working as a prostitute. This seems a bit of a leap to me. Why? Why go into prostitution. She’s supposedly from this fairly well off family. Well she was married and then widowed quite young. There may have been a baby. There may have been a child involved which pretty much excludes her from working in service. She didn’t appear to have a great relationship with her family. Those who knew her said she never communicated with them. So she must not have felt that she could go home. She also reported that, during this time living with her cousin, she was not well. She was in poor health and spent most of the time in an infirmary.
So bit of a downward spiral for Mary Jane sort of right off the bat here. In 1884 she moved to London. She would have been 21 years old. According to Joseph Barnett who she was sort of living with at the time of her death, he’ll come into the story soon, according to Joseph, Mary Jane began working at a high end brothel in the West End after arriving in London. So the West End, remember is the ritzy part of town. This is where the rich people live. Remember also that brothels are not legal in 1880s London, prostitution is but brothels are not. So this high end brothel would have been something that was kept, you know, on the DL and because it was in the West End, it would have been frequented by quite wealthy Londoners. Anything for rich people right. We’ll bend the rules for rich people. Her story gets a bit confusing after that. It appears she made her way to France at some point, possibly traveling with a man she had met at that West End brothel. She doesn’t stay there long though and eventually returns to London, to the East End where she bounces around quite a bit, living here and there and wherever she could.
Mary Jane was possibly also an alcoholic and, according to many many witnesses, she was the sort of alcoholic who was a completely different person when she was drunk than when she was sober. We have many witness accounts to support that. Elizabeth Phoenix, a woman whose brother in law Mary Jane had lived with for a time said that she was abusive and quarrelsome when she was drunk but quote “one of the most decent and nice girls you could meet when sober,” end quote. Her neighbor Catherine Pickett said quote “She was a good, quiet, pleasant girl and was well liked by all of us,” end quote. Her landlord John McCarthy said quote “when in liquor she was very noisy, otherwise she was a very quiet woman,” end quote.
In 1886, while living in a lodging house in Spitalfields which is a neighborhood in Whitechapel, she met a man named Joseph Barnett and they struck up a relationship of sorts. They start living together, bouncing around here and there. There are records of them being evicted for being drunk and for not paying their rent. In September of 1888 a Mary Jane Kelly is fined for being drunk and disorderly. Not sure if it’s the same Mary Jane Kelly but it’s of note. They clearly have problems with alcohol but they’re both described as being very nice, solid folk otherwise. Around September of 1888, Joseph Barnett lost his job. He was the financial provider for the couple. He would give Mary Jane money when she needed it so that she didn’t have to resort to sex work. Well at this point he loses his job, the money stops flowing, and Mary Jane goes back to sex work. What else is she going to do? Joseph is not cool with this. He leaves her where they were living in this tiny little one room situation at 13 Miller Court. Joseph moves out and leaves Mary Jane there alone. He later said he moved out because Mary Jane would let other prostitutes stay in their room and that was where apparently he drew the line.
This brings us to the evening of November 8th. Notice the 8th there. I know we skipped October 8th and October 30th for some reason but we are hitting on the 8th again here. Also this episode is coming out on November 8th. I swear I didn’t plan that y’all. At 11:45 Mary Jane is seen near her house at Miller Court with a man. This man is described as being around 35 years old, about 5’5”, shabbily dressed with a long overcoat and a bowler hat. He has a blotchy face and a quote “carroty mustache,” which I assume means it’s a reddish orange color, like a carrot? Or does that mean it's shaped like a carrot? I’m going with carrot colored. The man is carrying a pail of beer which I guess is like an oldschool six pack. Mary Jane says goodnight to her neighbor, Mary Ann Cox, who is the one reporting this sighting. She tells her quote “goodnight, I am going to sing.” And sing she does. Around 12:30 am, another one of Mary Jane’s neighbors, Catherine Pickett, says that she can’t sleep because of Mary Jane’s singing which she can hear through the wall or whatever. She wants to go tell her to stop singing but her husband stops her and says quote “you leave the poor woman alone.” The singing eventually stops because it seems Mary Jane goes out again apparently maybe to get some money. She is about to be evicted from her room at Miller Court because she can’t pay her rent.
At 2 am a man named George Hutchinson says he ran into Mary Jane and she asked him for money. He doesn’t have any to give her so she walks off and he sees her go up to another man a little ways down the street. He sees Mary Jane laughing with the man and they start to walk down the street together. Hutchinson says the man is carrying a small parcel. He describes him as having a pale complexion, a slight mustache turned up at the corners… later the newspapers will report that he had a dark complexion and a heavy mustache and I really think this is because they are still stuck on that initial appearance of John Piser, leather apron, who was cleared but whose physical description sort of stuck anyway as that of the killer… so this guy has a pale complexion, slight mustache, dark hair, dark eyes, and bushy eyebrows. Hutchinson says he looks Jewish… of course. He’s described as being around 35 years old. Same man as before? I don’t think so. He’s wearing a different outfit. He has on a felt hat, not a bowler hat, and a long dark coat, white collar, and black necktie. The other guy was described as shabily dressed. This guy doesn’t seem too shabby. Hutchinson apparently followed these two for whatever reason and notes that they stopped outside of Miller Court where Mary Jane lived and he heard her say quote “all right my dear, come along. You will be comfortable.” He puts his arm around her and she kisses him and then they head down Miller Court, presumably towards Mary Jane’s room. This report by Hutchinson will be heavily scrutinized later. There are many who think he made this whole thing up. There are some who think Hutchinson himself is actually the killer. We’ll come back to that.
At around 4 am, so an hour later, two of Mary Jane’s neighbors report hearing a cry of “Oh, murder!” like someone yelling out “Oh murder,” but they both roll over and go back to sleep. Apparently that isn’t a weird thing to hear in the middle of the night at Miller Court. At about 10:45 the next morning, a man named Thomas Bowyer is sent by the landlord to retrieve Mary Jane’s overdue rent money. He knocks on her door which is locked and then peers in the window, which of note was broken. The window had a broken pane of glass. Joseph Barnett said the window had been broken in an argument that they had when Mary Jane threw something at it or something. It had been broken for a while. So Thomas Bowyer looks in the window, and this is when he discovers the absolute horror of what has happened to Mary Jane Kelly. Here’s where it gets real bad guys. I questioned whether I should even reveal the extent of what happened to Mary Jane Kelly but I feel like I need to to do this story justice so here goes. Fast forward about a minute and half minutes if you’d like to be spared. Mary Jane was found lying on her back on the bed which took up most of the room. It was pretty much just a bed, a bedside table, and a fireplace. This was a very small room. According to Dr. Thomas Bond who responded to the murder scene quote “The whole of the surface of the abdomen and thighs was removed and the abdominal cavity emptied of its viscera. The breasts were cut off, the arms mutilated by several jagged wounds and the face hacked beyond recognition of the features. The tissues of the neck were severed all round down to the bone. The viscera were found in various parts viz: the uterus and kidneys with one breast under the head, the other breast by the right foot, the liver between the feet, the intestines by the right side and the spleen by the left side of the body. The flaps removed from the abdomen and thighs were on a table. The bed clothing at the right corner was saturated with blood, and on the floor beneath was a pool of blood covering about two feet square. The wall by the right side of the bed and in a line with the neck was marked by blood which had struck it in a number of separate splashes. The face was gashed in all directions, the nose, cheeks, eyebrows, and ears being partly removed. The lips were blanched and cut by several incisions running obliquely down to the chin. There were also numerous cuts extending irregularly across all the features. The neck was cut through the skin and other tissues right down to the vertebrae, the fifth and sixth being deeply notched,” end quote. She was mutilated beyond recognition, whole hunks of flesh cut off down to the bone. You can see pretty much all of her right femur in the top part of her leg. There is a photo of this crime scene which I agonized over whether or not I should include in the video version. I ultimately decided not to because it is truly so disturbing. Just Google Mary Jane Kelly and it will pop up if you really want to see it.
So, what really sets this murder apart from the 4 others that came before it, there’s the age difference, mid 20s instead of mid 40s, but there’s also the fact that she was killed inside, in her room which gave the killer way more time than he had had with the other victims. We’re talking hours instead of minutes. They have privacy. He can take his time and do what he really wants to do which is a lot, apparently, of truly bizarre and horrifying sick freak things. He also had light to see by. When they found Mary Jane there was evidence that there had been a roaring fire for some time in the fireplace in her room. It was stifling hot in there and it was likely that he kept that fire going so that he could actually see what he was doing for once.
And then… that was it. There were several more murders of women on the streets of Whitechapel after that, of course, but none quite with the right MO, none that are definitively linked to Jack the Ripper. And I find this really interesting. Why did he stop? Was this final act just so grand and over the top that it finally satiated his sick desires? Usually serial killers like this, at this level, only stop if they die or are arrested and imprisoned, that sort of thing. This is compulsive behavior. It’s an obsession, an addiction. They cannot stop otherwise. We’ve heard this from serial killers like Ted Bundy who explained it as an escalating force that he had no control over. He could not stop killing without external intervention. So it’s strange that we see the Jack the Ripper murders stop. It suggests that something happened to him. He died or was killed or somehow contained in jail or in an asylum or something like that.
And that brings us to the question of, who was this monster? Who was Jack the Ripper or, rather, “catch me if you can Mr. Lusk?” A criminal profile was not officially put together until 1988, one hundred years after the murders. Remember, this just wasn’t something that police were doing in the late 1800s. Also, they didn’t have that many serial killers back then. Serial killers are a bit of a newer social phenomenon scarily enough. Elliot Leyton writes in his book Hunting Humans that serial killers were relatively rare until the 1950s with about one serial killer arising each decade before that. But then, there were 6 identified in the 1960s. So we go from one per decade to six in one decade, in the 1960s. Then 1970s there are just under 20 serial killers identified and then in the 1980s it gets way crazy where we have a new serial killer literally every month just in the United States alone. So what the heck is happening here? I think, I’m gonna be real honest, I think it has to do with leaded gasoline. They first started putting lead in gasoline in the 1920s. Starting then, and all the way up into the 1990s when they finally stopped, people were breathing in leaded gasoline fumes which are super super toxic. Lead poisoning is known to cause cognitive impairment including lack of impulse control and increased antisocial and aggressive behavior. Is it a coincidence that the heyday of serial killers from the 1970s through the 1990s coincided with the decades people who breathed in constant lead fumes as children became adults? I think not. But, we’re off topic.
The first criminal profile of Jack the Ripper was in 1988 by American FBI profilers John Douglas and Roy Hazelwood. Based on everything we know about the murders, they compiled a list of traits that they believe the killer would have had. They said he would be a white male between the ages of 25 and 35. He lived locally in the Whitechapel area, probably in Spitalfields. This type of killer operates in familiar territory. He was probably a loner who was most likely unmarried. If he had been married it would have been to an older woman and only for a short time. As a child he would have had an absent father and a dominant mother figure. His mother probably had frequent encounters with many men that left him feeling neglected without consistent care. She may have even been a sex worker. He probably had a solitary job so he wasn’t around people much. He would have been seen as quiet and shy to people who knew him and probably a little odd. He may have had a physical or mental disability or deformity which made him feel different from others and affected his self esteem. This low self esteem would result in bouts of aggression and resentment especially after drinking. He probably drank at local pubs and, after a few drinks, found it much easier to converse with people. He likely dressed up when he went out looking for his next victim, wanting to appear like he had money and was trustworthy. These women were operating on the streets in the middle of the night talking to strangers, men they did not know, at a time when a known serial killer was hunting women of their exact type in that very neighborhood. They weren’t stupid. He had to have won them over and put them at ease with something like charisma. This is called a disarming charm. No, not expelliarmus. It’s something we see in a lot of serial killers, like Ted Bundy, for example, this ability to make victims feel at ease and like they can trust him. It’s likely he felt no remorse after the killings because he would have felt them justified. He often removed the sexual organs from these women. This says a lot. It suggests a deep hatred for women, really a fear of women, probably stemming from a negative relationship with his own domineering but neglectful and possibly abusive mother. In removing their female parts, the parts that make them women, he was removing their ability to scare him and giving himself power over them.
So, you know, this kind of just sounds like every single serial killer ever, unfortunately. Douglas and Hazelwood did confirm that this guy would not have stopped voluntarily. He would not have been able to stop. It’s not like he killed Mary Jane Kelly and then was like “eh, okay, that’s enough, I’m good.” They think it’s possible he was imprisoned for another, unrelated crime or that his family found out what he was doing and, instead of turning him into police, they had him committed to a mental asylum.
Noticeably absent from the FBI’s profile is work in the medical field as a doctor, physician, surgeon, someone with in depth anatomical knowledge. Douglas and Hazelwood did not think that the killer was necessarily a physician although they do concede that he had knowledge of anatomy. They think he may have gotten this from being something like a butcher, mortician’s assistant, medical examiner’s assistant, or hospital attendant instead. A butcher is especially promising as a lot of the organs that were removed and a lot of the mutilations we see to the bodies are more consistent with what you would see in a slaughterhouse than in a hospital.
So, who the heck was this guy? There has been a lot of very misleading chatter on the internet lately, I see this content all the time, about a man named Aaron Kosminski being 100% identified as Jack the Ripper. It’s click bait y’all. They’ll be like “Aaron Kosminski Identified as Jack the Ripper with 100% DNA match.” That is so misleading. Let me tell you the real scoop on Aaron Kosminski before we get into some other suspects. Aaron Kosminski was a Polish Jew who worked as a barber during the time of the murders. He was eventually committed to a mental asylum in 1891 where he died in 1919. So just right there he’s already sounding promising, right? Jewish? Mental asylum? Check. Check. The real breakthrough with Kosminski came from a shawl that was supposedly taken from the body of Catherine Eddowes. In 2019 this shawl was tested for DNA. This came back with a bloodstain with mitochondrial DNA matching a living descendent of Catherine Eddowes, not weird if it really was her shawl. It also came back with a possible semen stain with mitochondrial DNA matching a living maternal-line relative of Aaron Kosminski. So we have Aaron Kosminski DNA, possibly, on Catherine Eddowe’s scarf, possibly, case closed right? Well no, and here’s why. First we have major chain of custody problems. For evidence like a shawl to be, at least admissible in court, we have to maintain a chain of custody. We have to be able to prove that the shawl was taken from Catherine Eddowes crime scene and that it was not contaminated as evidence since then. We can’t even prove that the shawl was taken from Catherine’s crime scene much less what has happened to it since. The chain of custody is non-existent. Was it even Catherine’s shawl? Even that simple fact is just hearsay. Then we have issues with the DNA. It’s mitochondrial DNA which is a problem. Mitochondrial DNA cannot 100% identify a person, despite the misleading modern headlines about Aaron Kosminski. Thousands of unrelated people can share the same mitochondrial DNA profile. Thousands. And then, after this report came out in 2019, other researchers were like, where’s this shawl, where’s this evidence, we want to test it for ourselves and the researchers who were putting this stuff out were like “um, we don’t have it anymore, sorry.” Which is sketch. So, it’s really not conclusive at all. Could Aaron Kosminski have been Jack the Ripper? Yes. He lived in the East End in 1888 and his name came up in police reports as a possible suspect. He ended up in an asylum which is one way the murders might have stopped, if someone close to him realized what he was doing and had him committed but, he wasn’t committed until 1891, three years after the final murder. What made him stop for 3 years? That doesn't check out. That doesn’t fit the profile at all.
Let’s talk about some of the other major suspects. There, you guys, there are hundreds of Jack the Ripper suspects, hundreds. I’m going to focus on a handful of the more promising ones. And, this is going to be a long episode. Honestly, this should be a part 4 but I’m cramming it into part 3. Here’s a quick overview of suspects. First there’s Montague John Druitt. This guy was one of the original 3 police suspects named. He was a barrister which is like a lawyer and a school teacher. Those professions don’t fit the FBI profile at all so I’m already skeptical. He was found dead in the Thames River in December of 1888 which would explain why the killing stopped after Mary Jane Kelly in November of that year. And, his family later suspected him. But I feel like that could have just been because he was initially suspected by police and then died around the time the killings stopped. There’s really no other evidence. There’s nothing at all tying him to the murders outside of that and, in my mind, he just doesn’t fit the profile. A lawyer? A school teacher? Came from a respectable family. No. Maybe it’s because I’m a teacher, I’m so opposed to this one. A teacher wouldn’t do this y’all. No way. Leave this man alone. But, who knows.
Next up is Francis Tumblety. Tumblety was an Irish-born American and a self-proclaimed physician AKA a quack. He was in London during the murders and has a truly amazing mustache. He was arrested in November of 1888 on an unrelated charge which would explain why the murders stopped. He jumped bail and fled England. He wasn’t named as a suspect until 1913, I think just looking back and going “hmm, physician, in the right place at the right time, arrested just after the final murder. We should look at this guy” I don’t know. I don’t see him having intimate knowledge of the Whitechapel area. He was from the US. But, you know, a lot of those details check out.
George Chapman is another one, whose real name was Severin Klosowski, another pretty wild mustache. He was a Polish born barber same nationality and profession as Aaron Kosminski weirdly enough. He was also later a serial poisoner. He murdered three women using poison in the late 1890s and early 1900s. What does not check out for me with Klosowski is the very very different MO. Killing someone with poison is totally different than slitting someone’s throat and mutilating their body. Also, it’s a clear descalation. Also, what’s with the near 10 year gap with no murders? It does not fit the profile at all. Yes, he’s a murderer and he has a mustache but that’s about it.
We have George Hutchinson, the guy who gave the report of Mary Jane Kelly with that final man with the felt hat walking towards her room at Miller Court at 3 am the night she died. He gave a remarkably detailed report of this guy but investigators later questioned whether he had invented that whole story, just made it all up. Not really sure why that makes him a suspect. You can make up a witness account and not be the murderer. But I guess it could be seen as misdirection, misleading investigators. I don’t know. This one’s a stretch for me.
Jacob Levy has been proposed by more modern researchers. He was never named a suspect by police at the time. We’ve just found him looking back and going hmm. Levy was a butcher in Whitechapel. I feel like this is where he came from. That FBI criminal profile came out in the 1980s and someone was like “easy, give me the names of all the butchers in Whitechapel. Boom, Jacob Levy.” That’s pretty much the only thing making him a suspect, he lived in Whitechapel so he was familiar with the area and he was a butcher so he was familiar with anatomy and chopping up bodies and whatnot. I’m not convinced.
There’s James Kelly, unrelated to Mary Jane Kelly or John Kelly who Catherine Eddowes was sort of common law married to at the time of her death. James Kelly murdered his wife in 1883 and was thrown in an asylum for that. He escaped the Broadmoor Criminal Lunatic Asylum in January of 1888 and was at large during the Ripper murders later that year. They didn’t actually find him until 1927, though, so, once again, why did he stop? Why did he stop killing? This one’s very circumstantial. He did kill his wife. That’s very very different from what Jack the Ripper was doing.
James Maybrick is another rather dubious suspect. He wasn’t identified as a suspect until 1992 and what brought him into the suspect pool was a handwritten confession that was allegedly discovered in a diary 1992. Maybrick was a wealthy cotton merchant from Liverpool. So, not from Whitechapel, didn’t have knowledge of that area. Although people claim that he traveled a lot for work so he would have gone to London often. He also fits the physical description of the killer, which like which physical description? There are many. He’s well dressed with dark hair and a mustache. That’s also like almost every man in Victorian London. He also died in May of 1889 about 6 months after the last murder. The main reason he became a suspect is because of this diary presented by a scrap metal dealer named Michael Barret in 1992. The diary entry is a confession. Barret claimed that James Maybrick wrote it and it says that he traveled to London to commit the murders, fueled by drugs and a resentment towards his wife who was unfaithful. He signs the diary entry “yours truly, Jack the Ripper.” But Barret’s story changed about where he even got this diary from. At one point he even admitted it was fake and then recanted that confession. Most experts believe this diary entry was a hoax and not even a very good one. I’m not buying it because of that signature “yours truly, Jack the Ripper.” Pretty sure Fred Best at the Star Newspaper made up the name Jack the Ripper. I really don’t think the real killer would have even used it.
We’ll end it with one of the wilder suspect theories, although remember there are so, so many more so please don’t hate if I excluded your favorite suspect: Prince Albert Victor, grandson of then Queen Victoria and second in line for the throne. He was the oldest son of Victoria’s successor King Edward VII. He never took the throne because he died of pneumonia in 1892 when he was 28 years old. He was never, of course, he was never named as a suspect at the time. His name came up much later in the 1960s and 1970s when a conspiracy theory of sorts arose surrounding the Whitechapel murders claiming that they were a cover up by the royal family in order to silence these women who had learned of a scandal within the royal family involving Prince Albert Victor and an illegitimate child. This one is so far-fetched to me. These aren’t cover up murders. That’s not how you kill someone you’re trying to quietly silence. You slip some poison in their tea or whatever. You don’t openly and violently and horrifically mutilate them for all to see. You don’t want that kind of attention if you’re trying to sneakily dispose of someone. This theory doesn’t suggest that Prince Albert Victor himself was the murderer, he wasn’t even in London for like any of the murders. It suggests that the royal physician, Sir William Gull, was the one doing the actual murdering, like a hit man, and that he was guided around Whitechapel by an artist named Walter Sickert. This conspiracy theory actually came from Walter Sickert’s son Joseph who, by the way, later admitted that it was all completely made up. He made it up. But that did not stop, amazingly, that did not stop it from becoming a major Jack the Ripper theory, this Prince Albert Victor, Sir William Gull, Walter Sickert conspiracy trio. The idea was popularized in movies and books until people began to overlook the fact that it was complete garbage from the start.
You know I could go on and on and on with more and more suspects but this is already the longest episode of History Fix ever I’m pretty sure and the first ever part 3 so, you know, gotta end it somewhere. Jack the Ripper is truly a Pandora’s Box. When you open it it just does not stop, it goes deeper and deeper and twists more and more. You could explore this case forever and never run out of leads, never run out of theories, and suspects but how credible is any of it really? Remember, almost everything we know about Jack the Ripper came from newspapers. The official police records have been lost. The story of Jack the Ripper emerged, not as legit reporting of details in order to solve a series of horrific crimes, but as a way to sell newspapers. And it remained that way in the century that followed. No one's really trying to figure out who did this to these women. They are trying to sell books, trying to sell movies, trying to get notoriety, fame, fortune, clicks. They want clicks and views and subscribers. Aaron Kosminski is guilty 100% DNA match. No such thing with mitochondrial DNA, no such thing. We won’t tell them that part. They’ll click it anyway. Who knows, he might have done it. Click bait.
I realize the irony in pointing out the sort of unsavory way that the media has capitalized on the Jack the Ripper murders while myself, in some ways capitalizing on them. This is an interesting topic. It is a topic that a lot of people want to hear about. Some people will listen to History Fix for the first time to get this scoop. But I hope that the scoop that they get will be mostly rooted in fact, as much as is possible in a story this twisted, this telephoned. And I hope that what they take away will not be Aaron Kosminski scarf DNA or Prince Albert Victor illegitimate baby scandal. I hope it won’t be Severin Klosowski or Jacob Levy, Montague John Druitt or Francis Tumblety. I hope what they take away will be these names instead: Polly Nichols, Annie Chapman, Elizabeth Stride, Catherine Eddowes, and Mary Jane Kelly. Because the real story of Jack the Ripper is not about Jack the Ripper. Jack the Ripper is a made up name. It’s a name made up by newspapers to sell newspapers. The very name of the killer is click bait. This story is not about a man. It’s about women. It’s about women who were the victims, yes of a brutal and hate filled serial killer, but they were also victims of a society that created no space for them to exist. They had no opportunity, no support, no respect, no power. They were powerless to improve their own tragic positions in life, and then, rather than acknowledge what they were up against as women in a world that only valued men, as poor women in a world that only valued the wealthy, rather than do something to try to help, to try to fix that obvious failure present in society, people looked at their violent, senseless murders and said “good, one less unfortunate on the streets of Whitechapel. One less unsavory immoral woman, one less prostitute sullying our streets.” And then, even decades later, even a century or more later, rather than try to understand who these women really were, we’ve continued to dismiss them. We’ve focused instead on the man in the story. Who was that man? Was he a butcher? a doctor? a barber? Did he have a mustache? Was he 28 or 35? 5’5” or 5’9”? Was he Irish? Was he Jewish? The man has been immortalized, even revered. But this story isn’t about that man. Jack the Ripper was a loser. He was a nobody. This isn’t his story. He doesn’t hold the power. In the end, the women he killed are the victorious ones. Because in his cowardly, hate filled, low self esteem driven acts of violence, he exposed, not a man’s power, a man’s dominance over women. He exposed a broken and imbalanced male dominated society that we have been fighting, and winning, ever since to fix. That is what Polly, Annie, Elizabeth, Catherine, and Mary Jane won with their deaths, but only if we tell the story right. They won awareness and they won progress and that is true power.
Sources:







Comments